When a pastor falls from grace, the headlines focus on the scandalous details. The news coverage dissects the moral failure, the financial impropriety, or the abuse of power. But there's another story that rarely gets told—the story of the people left behind in the wreckage.
🎧 Listen to this episode:
These are the congregation members who showed up the Sunday after the announcement, unsure if they could sing worship songs without crying. The staff members trying to explain the unexplainable to their children. The volunteers defending their faith to skeptical coworkers while carrying their own quiet ache, wondering if they were naive or simply forgotten.
If you're a church leader navigating this kind of crisis—or preparing for the possibility—this post is for you. Because the truth is, how we care for people after a leadership failure matters just as much as preventing the failure in the first place.
The Secondary Wound Is Often Worse Than the First
We tend to view pastoral moral failure primarily as a leadership issue. And it is—don't misunderstand me. But at its core, it's also a pastoral care issue. The very people who need shepherding the most are often the ones whose shepherd has just been removed.
Consider what happened at Willow Creek. After allegations surfaced against the senior pastor, the board initially defended him and questioned the women who came forward. The response created a secondary trauma that rippled through the entire congregation.
Long-time members quietly slipped away. Survivors who had courageously shared their stories years later were re-traumatized—like ripping a bandage off a wound that had never properly healed. Staff morale didn't just decline; it imploded.
One victim captured the devastation perfectly: "I wasn't just hurt by the person who abused me. I was devastated by the church's response."
Ezekiel 34:4: "You have not strengthened the weak or healed the sick or bound up the injured. You have not brought back the strays or searched for the lost. You have ruled them harshly and brutally."
This pattern repeats itself in church after church. The initial wound from the pastor's failure is compounded by how the church handles the aftermath. And tragically, it's often this secondary wound that drives people away from faith entirely.
How Churches Mishandle the Aftermath
In my research on church scandals, I've observed a troubling pattern. Larger churches often have well-orchestrated responses—communication plans designed by professionals to manage the crisis. Smaller churches scramble just to figure out what to do on Sunday.
But regardless of size, churches consistently make similar mistakes:
They Silence or Sideline Victims
In an effort to "protect" the church's reputation, leadership often discourages victims from sharing their experiences or minimizes their pain. This compounds the trauma and sends a clear message about whose wellbeing really matters.
They Spin Public Statements to Manage Optics
The focus becomes saving face rather than seeking truth and justice. Carefully crafted statements prioritize the institution over the individuals who were harmed.
They Shame People Who Ask Honest Questions
Congregation members who seek transparency or accountability are often labeled as divisive or lacking faith. This shuts down necessary dialogue and healing.
They Rush to "Healing Services"
Before anyone has even named the pain or processed the trauma, churches schedule special services or events focused on "moving forward" and "healing." But you can't heal what hasn't been acknowledged.
Here's the reality: You can't crisis-proof a church by pretending nothing's wrong. That's not how genuine healing happens.
The Missing Element: Biblical Lament
Churches often jump from surprise to anger to "moving on"—but they skip a crucial biblical response: lament.
Throughout the Old Testament, we see leaders modeling lament as the language of spiritual honesty. They tore their clothes in grief. They wept publicly. They wrote songs that gave voice to their pain and disappointment.
Today, we're more comfortable with slick videos and healing weekends than we are with raw, honest grief. But here's what I've learned: You don't lead people well until you grieve what's been lost. You don't rebuild trust until you acknowledge the wreckage.
2 Corinthians 1:3-4: "Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of compassion and the God of all comfort, who comforts us in all our troubles, so that we can comfort those in any trouble with the comfort we ourselves receive from God."
People need permission to mourn. They need space to be angry, confused, and heartbroken. They need leaders who will sit in the mess with them rather than immediately trying to clean it up.
What People Really Need After Crisis
When a church is reeling from leadership failure, people need five things that all start with "T":
- Time - Healing can't be rushed
- Truth - Clear, honest communication about what happened
- Tears - Permission to grieve and lament
- Trauma care - Professional help for those who need it
- Trust-building - Consistent, transparent leadership over the long haul
You can't rush recovery. You have to let things breathe—and yes, they're going to bleed too. But that's part of the process.
Practical Steps for Church Leaders
Acknowledge what happened clearly and honestly. Don't minimize or spin. People deserve the truth.
Be present, human, and unpolished. This isn't the time for perfectly crafted messages. People need to see authentic leadership, not performance.
Bring in third-party help. Someone outside the situation can provide objective guidance and support that internal leadership can't.
Don't launch new initiatives. I recommend waiting at least a year before casting new vision or starting major programs. Focus on rebuilding trust first.
Show, don't just tell. Demonstrate your commitment to health and accountability through consistent actions over time.
Discussion Questions for Your Team:
- As a staff team, what safeguards do we have in place to protect both our leaders and our congregation?
- How can we better identify and care for people who may be carrying wounds from past church hurt?
- What's one specific way we can demonstrate trustworthy, accountable leadership to our congregation this month?
Sometimes People Don't Need a Fix—They Need a Shepherd
Here's what breaks my heart about many church scandals: In the rush to rebuild and rebrand, we forget that people aren't problems to be solved. They're sheep who've lost their shepherd.
The person who led them, prayed with them, officiated their weddings, and buried their loved ones has been removed from their lives—often dramatically and traumatically. They don't need a new vision statement. They need someone they can trust to walk with them through this valley.
1 Peter 5:2-3: "Be shepherds of God's flock that is under your care, watching over them—not because you must, but because you are willing, as God wants you to be; not pursuing dishonest gain, but eager to serve; not lording it over those entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock."
The People Left Behind Matter to Jesus
The congregation members processing pain in silence. The staff wondering if they can trust again. The victims who found courage to speak up. The families trying to rebuild their faith—they all matter to Jesus.
And if they matter to Jesus, they must matter to us.
Maybe your church isn't facing a crisis right now. That's a gift—use it wisely. Build the kind of culture where accountability is normal, where people feel safe to raise concerns, and where transparency isn't just a buzzword but a practice.
Action Steps for This Week:
- Identify 2-3 people in your congregation who may need extra pastoral care
- Schedule individual check-ins between senior leadership and each staff member
- Review your church's accountability and transparency policies
- Research local counseling resources for those healing from church trauma
The reality is this: Church scandals will continue to happen because churches are full of broken people, including broken leaders. But the wreckage doesn't have to be permanent. With the right response—one that prioritizes people over reputation—healing is possible.
It takes time. It takes truth. It takes tears. It takes professional trauma care. And it takes leaders committed to rebuilding trust one conversation, one decision, one day at a time.
The people left behind are counting on us to get this right.
This post is adapted from episode 552 of the Healthy Church Staff Podcast, part of a series based on my book "When the Church Falls." If you're a pastor or board member wondering how to build a healthier, safer church, I'd encourage you to start with the free assessment at whenthechurchfalls.com/assessment.
Have thoughts on this topic or questions about navigating church crisis? I'd love to hear from you at podcast@chemistrystaffing.com.
