<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=2300026853549930&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">
Skip to content
Staff Hiring

First Impressions Can Fool You: Vetting Personality in New Staff Hires

That initial sparkle can fade fast if unique personality differences exist. Look beyond simple likeability to ensure your new hire aligns where it counts.

Vetting Personality in Your Church Staff Hires

You’ve found a candidate you instantly click with.

 

They’re engaging, warm, great sense of humor. 

 

They’re the kind of person you’d bring home to momma.

 

You can’t wait to bring them on board to inject their personality into your team culture. 

 

But don’t let a winning first impression override personality fit. 

 

That initial sparkle can fade fast if underlying personality differences exist. Look beyond simple likeability to ensure your new hire aligns where it counts.

 

 

Why Personality Alignment Matters 

Every church has a collective personality made up of the staff, congregation, volunteers, and leaders. Before hiring a new staff member, it’s crucial to assess whether their personality is aligned with the church’s makeup. Just liking someone doesn’t mean your personalities mesh.

 

At Chemistry Staffing, we evaluate personality fit early through a 25-question personality assessment before candidates ever reach the interview stage. This screens for potential friction points or misalignment to prevent wasted interviews.

 

Go Beyond Likability 

Personality goes deep. Two candidates can have engaging, likable personalities on the surface. However, subtle differences in communication style, work pace, change orientation, and decision-making can cause issues.

 

Take time to explore candidates’ personalities beyond surface impressions. Get to know how they relate, work, and communicate to ensure alignment. Avoid forcing a square peg into a round hole.

 

Key Personality Questions  

Here are some key personality questions we recommend considering:

  • How would colleagues describe your personality and work style? 
  • When facing change, are you energized or cautious?  
  • Do you prefer shaping strategy or delivering consistent results?
  • How do you typically respond to conflict or disagreement?
  • How would you describe your ideal work culture?

 

Making personality fit a priority will prevent tension, burnout, and regrets down the road. 

 

Next Steps

Finding alignment in personality is vital but can be ambiguous to evaluate alone. At Chemistry Staffing, we specialize in assessing personality and work style fit. We take time to deeply understand your church’s collective personality and needs. Then we leverage our expertise to evaluate alignment and prevent potential friction points.

 

Don’t go it alone – let the experts help. Partnering with Chemistry can minimize the risk of a bad personality fit. We screen for fit all day long, exclusively for churches, because we know it matters. You don’t have to figure this out yourself.

 

Let’s start a conversation. Schedule a free 30-minute video call with one of our experienced church coaches. Ask us anything. We’d love to help however we can. Getting your next hire’s personality right is too important not to get guidance. We’re here to help.

 

 

Other resources for you on this topic:

 

We're on your side.  Let me know how we can help!

 

Todd

Todd Rhoades

Todd Rhoades

Todd has invested over 30 years in serving churches, having served as a worship pastor for over 15 years, a church elder for more than a decade, and in various ministry leadership roles in both the business and non-profit sectors. As the original founder and developer of ChurchStaffing.com, Todd fundamentally changed the way thousands of churches search for pastors and staff on the internet. Todd is a graduate of Cedarville University, and lives in Bryan, OH with his wife, Dawn.

Latest Resources

Finishing Strong: Leaving a Legacy that Matters

Finishing Strong: Leaving a Legacy that Matters

Discover the timeless wisdom of Apostle Paul and learn practical steps to finish strong in ministry, drawing inspiration to leave a lasting...

Apply Now! Worship Minister in Mechanicsville, VA

Apply Now! Worship Minister in Mechanicsville, VA

 Cool Spring Baptist Church in Mechanicsville, Virginia, is looking for a Worship Minister to lead its worship and music ministries.

Paul's Secret to Joyful Ministry

Paul's Secret to Joyful Ministry

Discover how to cultivate contentment in your ministry by learning valuable lessons from Apostle Paul's approach to finding joy and purpose...