Refining the Church Staff Hiring Process: Discernment Over Drama
Have you ever felt that the process of hiring for your church staff mirrors the plot of a reality TV show like "The Bachelor"? If you've found yourself trapped in a cycle of first impressions, shallow questions, quick decisions, and regret, you're not alone. However, it's time we refresh the approach.
The Bachelor Style Hiring Mistake
Many churches romanticize the hiring process, waiting for the perfect candidate – the 'one'. But in the quest for great vibes and immediate rapport, churches often oversimplify the hiring process, disregarding the complexity and necessity of alignment with the church's theology, mission, and culture.
'Vibe' hiring, like a flashy first impression or a shared joke during a coffee chat, isn't reliable or sustainable. Real-life ministry leadership demands more comprehensive evaluation, considering factors such as emotional intelligence, conflict style, communication, and more.
Redefining The Hiring Process: Structured and Spirit-Led
To cure the hiring headache of church staff, refine your process to a structured, Spirit-led strategy that focuses on real alignment rather than emotional highs. Following steps provide you a path to this upgraded approach:
-
Define Success: What does a win look like 12 months into the new hire? Identifying this before posting the job can help you outline evident parameters for the role.
-
Uniform Questioning: Ask the same questions to every candidate. It ensures fairness and consistency in the hiring process.
-
Leverage Assessments: Use assessments to gain objective insights on potential hires. Tools that evaluate personality, theology, leadership style, and team chemistry can help you spot patterns instead of fleeting moments.
-
Trust the Process: Add elements of discernment, prayer, and strategic planning in your hiring process. Resonate with the Holy Spirit in making these decisions, for he appreciates a well-executed process as much as he invites reliance on his leading.
The process may seem daunting, but remember, the real lives, spiritual wellbeing, and in fact, the future of many people, depend on the choices you make in staff hiring. Let's treat hiring as the sacred stewardship it indeed is – one that affects the eternal destiny of people and shapes the outreach, evangelism, and discipleship efforts of your church.
In conclusion, hiring shouldn't be a drama-filled guessing game. With discernment and clarity, you can build teams that are fit for purpose, and set to grow, last, and lead well. For more healthy church staff-related content, tune in today’s Healthy Church Staff Podcast episode here.
