You hired someone with an incredible resume. Great references. Strong gifting. A clear calling. Six months in, something feels off. The work's inconsistent, the attitude's shaky, the stories don't quite add up. And you're thinking: "How in the world did I miss this?"
🎧 Listen to this episode:
Here's the truth that every church leader eventually learns: You probably didn't miss it. The resume just bought them some time.
And if you've been in church leadership for more than a minute, you know exactly what I'm talking about. We've all been there—either as the hiring pastor wondering how we got it so wrong, or as the staff member watching a colleague's true colors emerge after the honeymoon period ends.
Resumes Open Doors. Character Keeps Them Open.
Let me be clear about something right from the start: Your potential will get you the interview. Your gifting might land you the job. But it's your character that determines whether you last.
In ministry, you can hide behind a great resume for about six months, maybe a year if you're really skilled at managing impressions. But eventually—always eventually—the real you shows up.
The way you handle conflict when emotions run high. The quality of your follow-through when no one's checking. How you treat the administrative staff when the senior pastor isn't in the room. That stuff can't be faked long-term. And in the pressure cooker of ministry life, where spiritual battles are real and margin is thin, character issues don't just surface—they explode.
We've Created a Culture That Overvalues Calling and Undervalues Consistency
Here's where it gets tricky, and this is something we see every single day at Chemistry Staffing. We've created a ministry culture that gets really excited about the person with the dramatic testimony, the one who can preach, lead worship, and connect with students all in the same weekend.
We ask about their calling story. Their passion. Their vision for ministry. All good things!
But we don't ask enough about their last three work situations. How they handled being corrected. Whether they actually finished what they started. If the people who worked alongside them would hire them again without hesitation.
We assume that calling equals character. And after working with thousands of candidates over the years, I can tell you with absolute certainty: it doesn't.
"Whoever can be trusted with very little can also be trusted with much, and whoever is dishonest with very little will also be dishonest with much." - Luke 16:10
We've been lied to. We've heard some whopper stories from people who supposedly were called by God to ministry. I'm not being cynical—I'm being realistic. The enemy loves to infiltrate God's work, and an impressive resume with questionable character is one of his favorite tactics.
Character Makes Gifting Sustainable
Now listen—I'm not saying gifting and calling don't matter. They absolutely do. God distributes spiritual gifts, and He calls people into specific ministry roles. That's biblical, and it's beautiful.
But here's what I've learned: Character is what makes gifting sustainable over the long haul.
You can be incredibly gifted and still be a nightmare to work with. You can have a crystal-clear calling and still be completely unreliable. You can preach a moving sermon on Sunday and leave a trail of broken commitments and hurt feelings Monday through Saturday.
What to Look For: Faithfulness Over Flash
So what should you actually be looking for—whether you're hiring or evaluating your own ministry health? Here are the questions that matter:
- Does this person do what they say they're going to do?
- Do they show up on time, consistently?
- Do they finish projects without constant supervision?
- Do they own mistakes, or do they deflect and blame?
- Are they kind to administrative staff and volunteers?
- Do they follow through on the small stuff?
Because if someone can't be faithful in the small things, your church will absolutely suffer when you give them bigger responsibilities. Jesus said this clearly in Luke 16:10, and it's proven true in every church I've ever worked with.
Discussion Question for Your Team
When you think about your current role, where do you lean more naturally: toward being "impressive" or toward being "consistent"? What's one area where the gap between your credentials and your daily work habits might be widest?
Your Reputation Is Being Built in the Unseen Moments
If you're the one being hired—or if you're currently serving on a church staff—listen carefully: Your reputation is being built in all those unseen moments.
Every email you send (or don't send). Every meeting you're late to. Every promise you make but don't keep. Every time you blame someone else instead of taking ownership. Every shortcut you take when you think no one's watching.
It's all building a reputation, brick by brick, day by day.
And here's what's wild about ministry: Your reputation travels faster than your resume. Churches talk to each other. References get called by people you don't even know about. LinkedIn messages get sent behind the scenes. Pastors meet at conferences and compare notes.
You might think you're starting fresh at a new church in a new city, but your character—good or bad—is going to follow you.
"A good name is more desirable than great riches; to be esteemed is better than silver or gold." - Proverbs 22:1
The Good News: You Can Build a Reputation for Both Faithfulness AND Excellence
Here's where I want to encourage you: You don't have to choose between being kind and being competent. This isn't an either/or situation.
You can be excellent at your job and humble in your relationships. You can be driven to accomplish great things for God's kingdom and still honor people in the process. You can have high standards for ministry quality and show grace when others fall short.
Ministry is a long game, friends. It's not about the impressive hire that makes waves in the first six months. It's not about the big launch or the viral moment or the initiative that gets your church mentioned at the conference.
It's about being the steady, faithful, "I can absolutely count on them" type of leader who's still here in five years. Still doing great work. Still growing. Still learning. Still leading well. Still honoring God and people.
That's the person every church is desperate to find. And that's the person you want to be.
Action Items for This Week
- Identify your "character weak spot." Write down one area where your work habits don't match your calling. Share it with a trusted team member.
- Do one "small thing" with unusual excellence. Pick a routine task and do it with a level of care that exceeds expectations.
- Conduct a personal integrity audit. Ask yourself: "If someone followed me around for a week, would they see consistency between who I say I am and how I actually work?"
Practical Advice for Church Leaders
If you're hiring: Slow down. I know you need to fill that position yesterday. I know the pressure is real. But take the extra time to check references that nobody gave you as official references. Ask about character, not just competency. Talk to the admin who worked with them. Call the volunteer who served under them. Do the detective work.
If you're being hired: Know that your reputation is your real resume. The references you're giving today aren't nearly as important as the reputation you're building with every interaction, every email, every commitment you make or break.
If you're already on staff: The way you're showing up today is writing your next reference letter, whether you realize it or not. Your character is either opening doors or closing them for your future ministry opportunities.
The Bottom Line
Your calling might get you the job, but your character determines whether you keep it and whether anyone will want to hire you after they know you.
At Chemistry Staffing, this is what we specialize in. It's not just about matching resumes to job descriptions. It's about character, competency, theology, culture fit, personality—all the things that create what we call a "healthy long-term fit."
By "long-term," we mean someone who can be on your team for the next five years or more. Because that's really where the deep, meaningful ministry starts—around years three, four, and five. That's when trust is built, when you know each other's strengths and weaknesses, when you can anticipate each other's needs and work together with gospel fluency.
But you can't get to year five if you don't make it past year one because character issues derailed everything.
"Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for human masters, since you know that you will receive an inheritance from the Lord as a reward. It is the Lord Christ you are serving." - Colossians 3:23-24
How We Can Help
Maybe you're reading this and thinking, "Todd, we don't have a good track record with hiring, and we're about to hire someone else. Can you help us?"
We'd love to. I'd love to hear your story and see if there's a way we can help you find not just a capable candidate, but someone whose character matches their calling.
You can reach out to me anytime—no pressure, no sales pitch—just a conversation about your needs and how we might be able to serve you: podcast@chemistrystaffing.com
Your character is your real calling card. Build it well.
What's Your Biggest Hiring Challenge?
I'd love to hear your story and the character questions you wish you'd asked during your last hiring process.
This post is based on Episode 664 of the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. Listen to the full episode for more insights on building healthy church teams that last.
