If you want to crisis-proof your church, here's a counterintuitive suggestion: don't start with the senior pastor.
🎧 Listen to this episode:
Start with the second chair.
Your executive pastor, associate pastors, and the people leading behind the spotlight—they see what nobody else sees. While all eyes focus on the senior pastor, your second-chair leaders know what everyone else knows and more. In church after church, they're the ones who either prevent the fall or watch helplessly while it happens.
After working with hundreds of churches through crisis situations, I've discovered something crucial: your second-chair leaders aren't just support staff—they're your crisis prevention system.
Second-chair leaders occupy a unique position in your church ecosystem. They're close enough to leadership to see the cracks forming, yet often positioned throughout the organization in ways that give them perspective the senior pastor simply can't have.
They notice when the senior pastor starts pulling away—sometimes before the senior pastor realizes it themselves. They see when feedback stops being welcomed, when the culture begins shifting, when small issues start snowballing into bigger problems.
But here's the critical question: Have you given them permission to say something?
"Though one may be overpowered, two can defend themselves. A cord of three strands is not quickly broken." - Ecclesiastes 4:12
Too often, second-chair leaders become reluctant observers, watching warning signs appear but feeling powerless to address them. They may fear overstepping boundaries, losing their jobs, or creating conflict. This is where many churches miss their best opportunity for early intervention.
Board members typically meet quarterly. Staff often see only what leadership wants them to see. But your executive pastor and second-chair leaders? They're in the room where it happens.
They can say the hard things—if they're empowered to do so. If the culture allows it. If they're not afraid of losing their job.
The healthiest churches I've worked with have executive pastors and second-chair leaders who have real authority to push back. Not as threats or challenges to authority, but as trusted partners in ministry.
In what ways do our second-chair leaders currently serve as "early warning systems" for potential problems? Where might we have blind spots?
Creating this kind of environment requires intentional effort from senior leadership. It means regularly asking questions like "What do you see that I might be missing?" and genuinely wanting to hear the answer—even when it's uncomfortable.
Here's what many senior pastors don't fully realize: while all eyes focus on the person in the pulpit, second-chair leaders are doing the heavy lifting that makes everything else possible.
They translate vision into execution. They manage the things the senior pastor won't, can't, or simply doesn't handle. They clean up messes they didn't make. And crucially, they often carry the emotional load of a team that's afraid to talk to the top.
If your executive pastor is burning out, that's a leading indicator. Pay attention.
"Moses' father-in-law replied, 'What you are doing is not good. You and these people who come to you will only wear yourselves out. The work is too heavy for you; you cannot handle it alone.'" - Exodus 18:17-18
The Exodus passage reminds us that even the most capable leaders need others to help carry the load. When second-chair leaders are overwhelmed, it's often because they're trying to compensate for gaps or problems in the leadership system.
Here's my challenge to senior pastors and church boards: invest in your second chair like your church depends on it. Because it does.
This investment goes far beyond salary and benefits. It means:
Remember: the strongest churches are led by teams, not solo acts.
Think of your second-chair leaders as your church's early warning system. They're positioned throughout your organization to spot potential problems before they become crises. But like any warning system, they only work if they're properly connected and empowered to sound the alarm.
This means creating regular touchpoints, establishing clear communication channels, and most importantly, fostering a culture where speaking up is seen as an act of love and faithfulness rather than disloyalty or insubordination.
"As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another." - Proverbs 27:17
The sharpening process isn't always comfortable, but it's essential for keeping leaders and organizations sharp and effective.
Your second-chair leaders aren't just support staff—they're your crisis prevention system. They have your back and want to have your back. The question is whether you're creating an environment where they can effectively fulfill that role.
If you're a senior pastor, look around at your second-chair leaders this week. Ask yourself: are they empowered truth-tellers or silent observers? The health of your church may depend on your answer.
If you're a second-chair leader feeling the weight of things you see but can't address, remember that your perspective is valuable. Find appropriate ways to share what you're observing. Your church needs your voice.
If you're navigating the complexities of second-chair leadership—whether as a senior pastor or in a second-chair role yourself—I'd love to help. My book When the Church Falls explores how to build cultures where truth gets told and leaders stay grounded.
Get your copy at whenthechurchfalls.com
Building a healthy church staff culture is complex work, and you don't have to figure it out alone. Whether you're dealing with hiring challenges, team conflict, or leadership development, we're here to help.
Have questions about empowering your second-chair leaders? I'd love to hear from you. Send me your thoughts and experiences at podcast@chemistrystaffing.com. We're in this together.