She was your rock. Your most reliable children's ministry volunteer who never missed a Sunday, always arrived early, and even bought her own supplies.
🎧 Listen to this episode:
Then three weeks ago, she vanished.
No resignation letter. No uncomfortable conversation. Just radio silence. You texted her twice and got back a polite "Sorry, just super busy right now."
You moved on because what else could you do? You've got a ministry to run and gaps to fill.
But here's what you probably need to know: Her time was worth $36 an hour, and you treated it like it was free.
If that statement makes you uncomfortable, keep reading. Because understanding the real value of volunteer time—and learning how to honor it—might be the most important thing you do for your ministry this year.
According to Ministry Watch, the calculated value of a volunteer hour in the United States for 2025 is $36.14.
That's not some feel-good, motivational number to put in your volunteer appreciation slideshow. That's the actual economic value—the market rate for the skilled labor your volunteers are providing absolutely free.
Let's do some quick math that might change how you think about your volunteer team:
When that reliable children's ministry volunteer ghosted your team, you didn't just lose someone to fill a schedule slot. You lost someone who was investing real, measurable, substantial value into your church's mission.
We obsess over staffing costs and budget line items for paid positions. But what about the unpaid staff who form the actual backbone of your church's operations? When was the last time you calculated their value—and adjusted how you treat them accordingly?
When volunteers disappear, we develop narratives that help us sleep at night:
These explanations feel true because sometimes they are true. Life genuinely gets complicated.
But most of the time? They left because we burned them out.
Here's what volunteer burnout actually looks like in the day-to-day operations of your ministry:
And then we wondered why they disappeared.
1 Peter 4:10 (NIV)
"Each of you should use whatever gift you have received to serve others, as faithful stewards of God's grace in its various forms."
Stewardship isn't just about money. It's about how we steward the time and gifts that people offer to God's work through your church. And right now, many of us are poor stewards of volunteer time.
Here's something that might sting a little: Most church staff don't realize that volunteer coordination is actually a huge part of their job.
You think your job title is "Youth Pastor" or "Worship Leader" or "Children's Director." But the reality? At least half of your role is recruiting, training, and retaining volunteers.
Most of us were never trained for this. We inherited broken volunteer systems and we're just trying to survive week to week, filling gaps and preventing weekend catastrophes.
But if you can figure out volunteer retention—if you can create systems that honor people's time and protect their capacity—you'll unlock potential you didn't even know existed.
You'll stop scrambling every weekend. You'll build a team that actually sticks around. And you'll create a ministry culture where people feel genuinely honored instead of subtly used.
Volunteers didn't sign up to fill every gap in your organizational chart. They signed up for a specific role with defined boundaries.
When you constantly shuffle people between positions or expand their responsibilities without asking, you're communicating that their preferences don't matter. That their time is infinitely flexible. That they exist to solve your problems.
Action step: Write down exactly what you're asking each volunteer to do. If it's expanded beyond their original agreement, have a conversation and get explicit permission before asking them to do more.
If you're texting volunteers at 10 PM asking if they can serve tomorrow morning, you don't have a staffing problem. You have a systems problem.
Every last-minute text, every "quick favor," every unexpected role change sends a message: "I didn't plan ahead because your time isn't worth planning for."
Action step: Create scheduling systems that give volunteers at least two weeks' notice. If you can't staff something with that much runway, the problem isn't your volunteers—it's your planning process.
Skip the blanket "thanks to all our volunteers" announcement from the stage.
Instead, name people specifically. Text them personally—not in a group thread. Write actual notes. Tell them exactly what their contribution made possible.
You would never forget to pay a $36-an-hour employee their wages. Don't forget to honor a $36-an-hour volunteer with genuine, specific gratitude.
Action step: Block 30 minutes on your calendar this week specifically for thanking volunteers. Not asking for anything. Not recruiting. Just expressing genuine appreciation for the value of their time investment.
Most volunteers who leave never told you they were frustrated. They just quietly faded away because speaking up felt awkward or risky.
What if you regularly asked: "What's working well in this role? What's frustrating? What would make your serving experience better?"
Action step: Ask 3-5 volunteers confidentially this week: "When you serve here, what feels like a waste of your time?" Listen without defending yourself. Just listen.
Colossians 3:23-24 (NIV)
"Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord, not for human beings, since you know that you will receive an inheritance from the Lord as a reward. It is the Lord Christ you are serving."
When you honor volunteer time like it's actually worth $36 an hour—because it is—you'll stop losing volunteers like they're worthless.
Your volunteers aren't ghosts. They're not flaky. They're not uncommitted.
They're people with real lives, real capacity limits, and real value they're choosing to invest in God's Kingdom through your church.
Treat their time like the gift it is, and most of the time, they'll keep giving it.
Calculate your ministry's "time cost": Add up volunteer hours in your ministry area for one month and multiply by $36. Share this number with your team to create awareness of the investment being made.
Review one volunteer role: Pick the position with the highest turnover. Rewrite the role description with time efficiency in mind. Cut anything that doesn't directly serve the mission.
Audit your communication: Review the last five emails or texts you sent to volunteers. Could the information have been communicated more efficiently? Commit to clear, concise messaging going forward.
I'd love to hear your experience with volunteer retention. What's working in your church? Where are you struggling? What questions does this raise for your specific ministry context?
Send your thoughts to podcast@chemistrystaffing.com. I read every email, and your real-world experiences help shape future conversations.
And if you found this helpful, would you share it with another church leader who might need to hear it? Sometimes the best thing we can do for each other is simply say, "You're not alone in this."
Want to assess the overall health of your church staff culture? Take our free Church Staff Health Assessment at churchstaffassessment.com.
This post is based on episode 707 of the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. New episodes drop every weekday.