The most important number in your church isn't your attendance. It isn't your budget or your giving either. It's the one person standing in your pulpit, and what's actually in their chest.
🎧 Listen to this episode:
I've worked with hundreds of churches over the years, and here's what I've noticed: I can tell the whole DNA of a church by their pastor. The senior leader you choose—or the leader you're becoming—has the power to change the trajectory of your entire church and maybe even your community.
Either up for the positive or down.
On one hire. On one decision.
So whether you're on a search committee right now or you're serving on staff somewhere, this matters to you. Because there's a biblical principle at work here that changes everything about how we hire leaders and how we evaluate our own effectiveness in ministry.
We've been spending time in 1 Samuel 16 this week, looking at how God picks a leader. The heart over the outward appearance. But here's the promise that underlies all of it, found in Jeremiah 3:15:
"I will give you shepherds after my own heart, who will lead you with knowledge and understanding."
That's not a suggestion. That's God on the record. He intends to give his people leaders who match his own heart.
But let's be honest about what's at stake here when you're hiring a senior pastor.
A senior pastor isn't really a hire in the traditional sense. It's so much more than that.
It's a decade of somebody's life braided into yours.
Think about it: This person will preach every week. They'll probably marry your kids. Bury your parents. Sit at the hospital with you or a loved one at 2 a.m. Whoever stands in that pulpit sets your church's spiritual weather for years to come.
I was talking with my wife recently about all the churches I get to work with, and it struck me how clearly I can see this pattern. The senior pastor shapes everything—the culture, the DNA, the direction, the spiritual temperature of the entire congregation.
Get this hire right, and it could compound for a whole generation. Get it wrong, and... well, you understand the stakes.
That's why God's criteria matter so much. He's not looking at what we typically look at.
Here's where it gets personal for every staff member listening—not just the search committee folks.
If the Lord looks at the heart when he hires, guess what he looks at while you serve?
Not your platform.
Not your numbers.
Not how last Sunday went.
Your heart.
Now listen—this is the most freeing thing I can say to a tired church staff member:
You've been grading yourself on the outward. God never was.
You're exhausted trying to meet metrics that God isn't even tracking. Meanwhile, the one thing He's actually watching—the condition of your heart—often goes completely untended.
"The LORD is my shepherd; I shall not want. He makes me lie down in green pastures. He leads me beside still waters. He restores my soul. He leads me in paths of righteousness for his name's sake."
This foundational passage reminds us that before we shepherd others, we are sheep who need the Good Shepherd's care, provision, rest, and restoration.
So here's my question for you: When did you last tend your own heart—not just your output?
The platform is loud. The heart is quiet. Guess which one we let go untended?
A shepherd after God's heart isn't first a better communicator. He's a tended soul. The same is true for you, regardless of your role.
Your best ministry flows out of a heart that somebody's actually paying attention to. And that somebody has to be you.
You can't give away what you don't possess. You can't lead people to green pastures you've never found yourself. You can't point people to still waters when your own soul is parched and running on fumes.
"Son of man, prophesy against the shepherds of Israel... Should not shepherds feed the sheep? You eat the fat, you clothe yourselves with the wool, you slaughter the fat ones, but you do not feed the sheep. The weak you have not strengthened, the sick you have not healed..."
A sobering warning about shepherding for self-benefit rather than for the sheep's welfare—a danger every staff member must guard against.
God looks at the heart when he hires, and he looks at the heart while you serve. Tend the thing he's actually watching.
The soul under the work? That's the actual work.
First, if you're hiring: Pray Jeremiah 3:15 over your search, out loud. Write it down right now. It's God's promise—hold him to it. Don't settle for the impressive resume or the polished interview. Ask God to show you the heart behind the performance.
Second, whatever your role: Block thirty minutes this week for your heart. Not your to-do list. Not sermon prep. Not your strategic planning. Your heart.
Sit with God. Let Him shepherd you. Find your green pastures. Drink from still waters. Experience soul restoration.
Because you simply cannot lead people where you haven't been yourself.
Here's what I want you to remember: God already picked. He looks at the heart. And he keeps his promise to send shepherds after his own.
If your church is in a senior pastor search right now, or if you're building out your staff team and want to partner with someone who screens for the heart—not just the resume—that's what we do at Chemistry Staffing. It's why we exist.
My team and I would be honored to serve you in this process. You can reach out to me directly at podcast@chemistrystaffing.com or learn more at ChemistryStaffing.com.
And if this resonated with you, would you share it with your team? Maybe send it to your search committee or other staff members who need this reminder. Sometimes we all need permission to stop grading ourselves on metrics God never cared about in the first place.
The Lord looks at the heart. So can we.
I'd love to hear from you. What resonated most? What's one step you're taking this week to tend your heart?
Email me your thoughtsThis post is based on Episode 688 of the Healthy Church Staff Podcast. Subscribe to get fresh insights for church leaders every weekday.