Church Leadership | Chemistry Staffing

Silent Alarm: Stop Trying to Rebuild Alone

Written by Todd Rhoades | Aug 29, 2025 10:00:00 AM

Opting Out of Isolation: The Key to Rebuilding Church Staff

In the mission to rebuild church staff, many church leaders often bear the burden alone – they recruit, interview, evaluate, onboard and attempt to fix the culture singlehandedly. However, this approach is crushing and unnecessary, leading to an overwhelmed and isolated leadership. The process of rebuilding your church staff is complex, emotional, spiritual and strategic, therefore requiring an empathetic and collaborative approach.

The Pitfalls of a Lone Leadership

When church leaders isolate themselves in the process of rebuilding, they risk burning out or blowing up. Regardless of how control over the situation this might feel like it offers, remember that in reality, such isolation can actually lead to collapse. The belief that you need to carry the weight of your staff solo is far from noble. In fact, it's destructive.

A Collaborative Approach to Rebuilding Church Staff

If you're committed to rebuilding your church staff efficiently and sustainably, consider implementing a collaborative strategy. This strategy should comprise four essential elements:

  • Wise Counsel: Seek advice from reliable sources who can offer objective perspectives.
  • Collaborative Process: Involve your board, staff and trusted leaders in meaningful conversations.
  • Outside Voices: Engage external experts who can objectively identify and address any existing or potential issues.
  • Spiritual Dependence: Understand that rebuilding your staff isn't exclusively about strategy. It's equally about obedience and spirituality.

Embrace Effective Rebuilding Strategies

Instead of only praying for the future direction of your church staff on your own, invite your team to join you in seeking divine guidance. Likewise, don't simply rely on your own judgment when reviewing candidate resumes. Rather, seek the viewpoints of diverse individuals to promote a nuanced decision-making process. Avoid the trap of hoping that a new hire will fix everything. Instead, address underlying issues head-on and resist following the loudest voice; instead, seek the wisest.

Ministry leaders need to recognize that rebuilding church staff is a mission too important and too complex for any one person to try and tackle alone. The most resilient churches are the ones that understand this and work together towards their common goal.

Learn more about effective strategies for rebuilding your church staff in my latest book "Silent Alarm - The Quiet Collapse of the Church Staff Pipeline and How to Rebuild it Before it's Too Late". For more insights on this topic, tune into today’s Healthy Church Staff Podcast episode. Let’s untangle the complexities of the rebuilding process together.